Search this website
| Options Options
Search Type
Company to pay contractor $80,000 after tree trunk fractures skull
Document Actions

Company to pay contractor $80,000 after tree trunk fractures skull

5 May 2015

Gardening business Hao & Liu Union Limited has been ordered to pay reparation of $80,000 after a contractor suffered a severe brain injury and a depressed skull fracture when a tree trunk struck him on the head and back. He underwent two surgeries as a result and has since returned to China where he will continue to receive rehabilitation.

Hao & Liu Union Limited was sentenced in the Auckland District Court under the Health and Safety in Employment Act for failing to take all practicable steps to ensure the contractor’s safety.

The man had only been contracting for Hao & Liu Union Limited for a few weeks when he has contracted, along with others, to remove two trees from the Avondale Motor Park on 14 July 2014. His job was to remove falling tree branches and put them through a wood chipper.

Later in the day, the arborist was cutting off the top section of the tree trunk not realising that the man was under the tree. The arborist pushed off the cut section of the truck and then heard a shout. As he looked down he saw the tree trunk hitting the contractor.

“Hao & Liu Union Limited had not adequately trained and supervised the contractor,” says Keith Stewart, Chief Inspector at WorkSafe New Zealand.

“They should have ensured there was clear communication between the arborist and other workers, and marked out unsafe areas under and around the tree. This simple step would have ensured that the ground crew knew to keep out of those areas.

“The man was also not wearing his safety helmet or his high-visibility clothing in the areas where they were cutting down the tree.

“These were all practicable steps that the company should have taken to keep people safe.”


Media centre

To view all of the latest media releases for WorkSafe New Zealand please visit our Media centre.

Media centre

Media contact details

For more information contact our Media Desk:

Phone 021 823 007 or